One of the first questions travelers ask is when planning a trip to Iceland is: should I rent a car or take the bus? Iceland’s epic landscapes, sprawling countryside, and unique attractions make transportation a key part of the adventure. And while public buses may seem like an economical or eco-friendly option, they come with significant limitations that could restrict your experience.
In this guide, we’ll compare renting a car versus taking the bus in Iceland from convenience and cost to access, flexibility, and safety. Highlighting how renting a car unlocks the true magic of Iceland’s roads, especially for families, couples, and anyone seeking comfort, independence, and adventure.
Pros of taking the bus in Iceland
Buses in Iceland can be a good option if you’re staying primarily in Reykjavík or visiting only the most popular and accessible tourist attractions. Public transport offers a relatively low-cost way to get around for travelers who prefer not to drive or are taking short day trips without venturing far from the capital. Bus routes like Stræto's network or tour-oriented services such as Reykjavik Excursions operate fairly well within the capital region and connect some major landmarks.
This option may suit travelers who have a rigid itinerary, are traveling solo, or are on a tight budget. Additionally, for those who are not comfortable driving in a foreign country or during Iceland's winter months, bus travel removes the responsibility of navigating road conditions. Some key advantages include:
- Lower upfront cost: Bus tickets may be cheaper than renting a car, especially if you're traveling solo and making only a few stops.
- No driving required: Ideal if you’re uncomfortable driving in a foreign country or during winter.
- Eco-friendly choice: Public transportation produces fewer emissions per person.
Some bus lines, like Stræto or long-distance services such as Reykjavik Excursions, can connect you to popular destinations like the Blue Lagoon, Þingvellir National Park, or Akureyri. But those conveniences come with trade-offs.
Cons of taking the bus in Iceland
While buses offer some advantages for budget or solo travelers, they are not ideal for those looking to fully experience Iceland’s diverse and often remote landscapes. Public transportation in Iceland is not as expansive or frequent as in many other countries, which makes it difficult to rely on buses for a flexible or spontaneous journey. Tourists who want to explore multiple regions, make scenic stops, or travel beyond major hubs often find themselves limited by the reach and reliability of the bus network. These drawbacks can significantly impact your overall experience. Key downsides include:
- Limited schedules: Buses don’t run frequently and often only operate once per day to key destinations.
- No access to remote areas: Many of Iceland’s top natural attractions—like Highland routes, hidden waterfalls, and scenic stops—are inaccessible by bus.
- No flexibility: You’re bound to fixed timetables and routes. Missing a bus could throw off your entire day.
- Difficult in winter: Icy or stormy weather may lead to cancellations, leaving you stranded.
- Inconvenient for families: Traveling with kids, strollers, or extra luggage on a bus can be exhausting.
Ultimately, taking the bus can restrict your itinerary, force compromises, and create unnecessary stress.
Pros of renting a car in Iceland (with Blue Car Rental)
For those wanting the freedom to explore Iceland on their own schedule, renting a car is the clear winner. Unlike public transportation, a rental car allows you to design a fully personalized itinerary, travel at your own pace, and make spontaneous stops at stunning viewpoints, hidden hot springs, and less-traveled trails. This level of autonomy is especially valuable in Iceland, where the true magic often lies off the beaten path. Renting a car also eliminates the stress of rushing to catch a bus, juggling fixed timetables, or rearranging your trip because of limited transportation.
Whether you're traveling solo, as a couple, or with family and friends, a rental car enhances your comfort and convenience. With Blue Car Rental, you'll also benefit from local knowledge, a wide range of vehicle options, and full coverage that ensures peace of mind on the road. Here’s why renting a car is often the smarter, safer, and more rewarding choice:
- Total freedom and flexibility: Leave when you want, stop where you want, and explore off-the-beaten-path spots.
- Access to remote destinations: Drive to places that buses can’t reach—like Landmannalaugar, Snæfellsnes, or the East Fjords.
- More efficient travel: Save time compared to waiting for and riding buses.
- Comfort and privacy: Great for couples, families, and solo travelers wanting a peaceful ride.
- Ideal for all seasons: Rent a 4x4 in winter or a fuel-efficient car in summer.
- Convenient for families: Load up child seats, luggage, snacks, and travel stress-free.
- Blue Car Rental extras:
- No deposit required
- Full Zero Worries insurance coverage
- Online check-in and fast pickup
- Airport and Reykjavik City office locations
- Local support and roadside assistance
Whether you’re planning a Golden Circle day trip, a multi-day adventure on Iceland's highland routes, or a full Ring Road journey around the island, Blue Car Rental helps you do it your way. Their flexible service allows you to build an itinerary that matches your pace, interests, and travel style, without the limitations of public schedules or fixed routes. With their wide fleet, fast check-in system, and excellent local support, Blue Car Rental empowers you to make the most of every mile on Iceland’s breathtaking roads.
Cons of renting a car (And how to prepare)
Renting a car in Iceland does require some responsibility and planning, but nothing you can’t handle.
- Driving experience: You’ll need to be comfortable behind the wheel, especially in winter.
- Higher upfront cost: Compared to a basic bus fare, renting costs more—but gives much more value in return.
- Route planning needed: You’ll need to map your journey—but GPS and Blue Car Rental’s expert staff make it simple.
Prepare well, and a rental car becomes your ticket to flexibility and freedom. Make sure to check local weather conditions and road updates daily via reliable Icelandic sources such as vedur.is and road.is, especially if you’re traveling during winter or heading to rural regions. Dress in layers appropriate for Iceland’s ever-changing climate and carry essentials like a map, phone charger, snacks, and water. Lastly, opt for comprehensive insurance like Blue Car Rental’s Zero Worries package, which provides peace of mind by covering wind, gravel, and other unique driving risks you may encounter in Iceland.
When renting a car is the better choice
Deciding how to travel around Iceland can dramatically shape your experience. While buses might suffice for minimalist travelers based in Reykjavík, most visitors benefit greatly from the comfort, flexibility, and adventure that come with renting a car. Iceland is a land of winding fjords, remote waterfalls, and unexpected wonders that are often far off the main road and public transport simply can’t reach them.
Renting a car allows you to control your itinerary, explore hidden gems at your own pace, and respond to changing weather or road conditions without relying on rigid schedules. It’s ideal for travelers who want the freedom to stop at scenic overlooks, visit lesser-known landmarks, and take detours whenever curiosity strikes.
It’s the best option for:
- Families and small groups: Enjoy space for luggage, car seats, snacks, and gear.
- Couples wanting flexibility and comfort: Private travel makes romantic getaways smoother and more enjoyable.
- Winter travel or shoulder seasons: 4x4 vehicles with proper tires are essential for safety.
- Exploring the Ring Road, South Coast, or Westfjords: These routes are spectacular—but hard to access without a car.
- Visiting national parks, hidden hot springs, and remote natural wonders: Many iconic spots like Landmannalaugar or Hvitserkur are unreachable by bus.
- Photography, wildlife watching, and scenic stops: Pull over anytime to capture Iceland’s incredible views.
- Travelers on tight schedules: Make the most of every hour instead of waiting for buses.
With Blue Car Rental, you can rest easy knowing you’re getting much more than just a vehicle. You’re gaining the security of full coverage with the Zero Worries insurance, local road expertise, quick and easy pickup at both Keflavík Airport and downtown Reykjavík, and a wide fleet to fit every itinerary. Their no-deposit policy and contactless key-box pickup make your journey even smoother.
In short, if you want to truly experience Iceland, on your terms, a rental car isn’t just the better choice. It’s the best one.
Travel time comparison: Car vs. bus in Iceland
To help you better understand the difference in convenience and flexibility, here’s a quick comparison of estimated travel times by car versus bus to some of Iceland’s most popular destinations from Reykjavík:
Destination | By Car (approx.) | By Bus (approx.) |
---|---|---|
Thingvellir National Park | 45 minutes | 1.5–2 hours |
Blue Lagoon | 50 minutes | 1.5–2 hours |
Reynisfjara black sand beach - Vik | 2.5 hours | 4–5 hours |
Gullfoss Waterfall | 1 hour 45 minutes | 3–4 hours |
Jökulsárlón Glacier Lagoon | 5–6 hours | 10+ hours |
Akureyri (North Iceland) | 4.5–5 hours | 7–8 hours |
Snæfellsnes Peninsula | 2.5 hours | 4–6 hours |
Please note that bus travel times can vary greatly depending on the number of stops, transfer points, and seasonal availability.
Final thoughts
While bus travel may seem budget-friendly, the reality is that it limits your freedom, flexibility, and access. Renting a car in Iceland, especially with a reliable partner like Blue Car Rental opens the door to a more complete, comfortable, and memorable adventure.
It also ensures safer travel. Iceland’s weather can shift rapidly, and rural roads like in winter, may be icy or difficult to navigate. Renting a car allows you to check weather forecasts and road conditions daily on safetravel.is, take breaks as needed, and adjust your route for safety. Wearing appropriate layers and driving a properly equipped vehicle, like a 4x4 in winter, is essential for a safe experience. Add in the peace of mind provided by Blue Car Rental’s Zero Worries insurance, and you’re prepared for whatever the road may bring.
From easy pick-up at Keflavík Airport or downtown Reykjavík, to full insurance coverage and a wide vehicle selection, Blue Car Rental gives you the keys to travel at your pace, with safety, comfort, and confidence.
Book now and make the most of your Icelandic adventure with Iceland's top rated car rental.